
Old Faithful Inn
Best for history and being steps from the Old Faithful geyser and the park’s Upper Geyser Basin.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Old Faithful Inn is a National Historic Landmark log lodge inside Yellowstone National Park for travelers who want a historic, unplugged park stay near Old Faithful. Starlite Yellowstone, Tapestry Collection is an upscale Hilton-affiliated hotel in West Yellowstone for travelers who want newer, branded comforts (pool, waterslide, a hot tub) close to the park entrance.
Updated · about 21 miles (34 km) apart

Best for history and being steps from the Old Faithful geyser and the park’s Upper Geyser Basin.

Best for families and travelers who want hotel-style amenities (heated indoor pool, waterslide, hot tub) and Hilton rewards in West Yellowstone.
Old Faithful Inn wins when you want to stay inside Yellowstone in a National Historic Landmark, prioritize proximity to Old Faithful and the park experience, and accept a deliberately unplugged, seasonal stay.
Starlite Yellowstone, Tapestry Collection wins when you want contemporary, branded comforts — indoor pool, waterslide, fitness facilities and a full-service hotel experience — based in West Yellowstone near the park’s west entrance.
Bottom line: choose Old Faithful Inn for the historic, in-park geyser experience; choose Starlite Yellowstone for newer, amenity-rich lodging and easier access to town services and the West Entrance.
| Category | Old Faithful Inn | Starlite Yellowstone, Tapestry Collection |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic, rustic, intentionally unplugged | Contemporary, branded, amenity-forward |
| Location | Inside Yellowstone National Park next to Old Faithful (walkable) | In West Yellowstone, Montana — near the West Entrance and town attractions |
| Distance between hotels | about 21 miles (34 km) to West Yellowstone | |
| Size (rooms) | 327–329 rooms (historic lodge) | 133 rooms (Hilton Tapestry listing) |
| Ages / check-in policy | All ages welcome; minimum check-in age 21 unless with guardian | All ages welcome; property is family-friendly (no adults-only policy published) |
| Pools & water features | No pool, hot tub, or spa on site | Indoor pool, waterslide, heated pool and hot tub |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple outlets: Old Faithful Inn Dining Room, Bear Pit Lounge, Bear Paw Deli, Espresso cart | HB on Madison (1 restaurant) and on-site dining services |
| Wellness & fitness | No spa or fitness center on site; active outdoor options nearby (hiking, biking) | Fitness facilities on site; additional recreational features (arcade, waterslide) |
| Accessibility & family features | Some elevator access; some historic rooms have shared bathrooms; family-friendly | Accessible rooms listed; multiple mobility and hearing-accessible room types; family rooms and suites |
| Known for | Staying inside the park in a landmark lodge within walking distance of Old Faithful | Upscale, Hilton-affiliated hotel in West Yellowstone with pool, waterslide, and family amenities |
Old Faithful Inn sits inside Yellowstone National Park a short walk from Old Faithful geyser and the Visitor Education Center.
Choose the Inn for direct access to geysers and park trails; expect a park-centered, quieter stay.
Starlite Yellowstone sits in West Yellowstone, close to the West Entrance and town attractions.
Choose Starlite for easy access to town services and the West Entrance for park exploration.
Old Faithful Inn rooms are designed to preserve the historic lodge experience, with a mix of private and some shared-bathroom rooms.
Expect simple, historic rooms focused on the park experience rather than modern in-room tech.
Starlite Yellowstone offers a contemporary set of room types, including many accessible and family-friendly layouts.
Expect modern in-room conveniences, multiple family/accessible room options, and Hilton-style comforts.
Old Faithful Inn has several on-site dining venues centered on the historic Dining Room and casual outlets.
Choose Old Faithful Inn for historic dining settings and easy access to geyser-viewing spots after meals.
Starlite Yellowstone has one primary on-site restaurant and typical hotel dining services.
Expect a single on-site restaurant for main meals and convenient grab-and-go or town dining nearby.
Old Faithful Inn does not provide a pool, hot tub, or spa, focusing instead on the park setting and geothermal attractions.
If a hotel pool or spa is a must, Old Faithful Inn is not the right choice.
Starlite Yellowstone lists a heated indoor pool, waterslide and a hot tub as key recreational features.
Starlite is a better pick for travelers prioritizing an indoor pool, waterslide and family-friendly water features.
Old Faithful Inn has no spa or fitness center; outdoor activities and daytime hikes are the main wellness options.
Plan active outdoor days and simple on-site evening options at the Inn.
Starlite Yellowstone provides fitness facilities and more on-site recreational choices suited to families.
Starlite fits travelers who want an on-site fitness option and family entertainment after park days.

Old Faithful Inn — walk to Old Faithful and the Upper Geyser Basin.

Starlite Yellowstone — indoor heated pool, waterslide and hot tub appeal to families and kids.

Old Faithful Inn — a National Historic Landmark and log lodge experience inside the park.

Starlite Yellowstone — Hilton Tapestry branding, many accessible room types, and modern in-room features.
Old Faithful Inn — it’s within a 5–10 minute walk of the geyser and the Old Faithful Visitor Education Center.
Starlite Yellowstone — the supplier listing shows an indoor heated pool, a waterslide and a hot tub; Old Faithful Inn has no pool or hot tub.
No — Old Faithful Inn intentionally provides an unplugged room experience without TVs, radios, air conditioning or in-room internet; Starlite Yellowstone does provide Wi‑Fi and TVs.
Starlite Yellowstone — it’s located in West Yellowstone near the West Entrance, town restaurants, and visitor services.
No — both properties welcome guests of all ages; neither is adults-only.
Explore how Old Faithful Inn stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·