
Old Faithful Inn
Best for staying inside Yellowstone, walking to Old Faithful and easy access to geyser viewing.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Old Faithful Inn is a historic log lodge inside Yellowstone National Park best for travelers who want to stay steps from Old Faithful and the Upper Geyser Basin. GetAways at Timbers at Island Park is a small resort-style condo property in Island Park, Idaho, aimed at travelers who prefer larger condo space, kitchens and an indoor pool farther from the park.
Updated

Best for staying inside Yellowstone, walking to Old Faithful and easy access to geyser viewing.

Best for travelers who want condo space, a kitchen and an indoor pool while staying outside the park in Island Park.
When Old Faithful Inn wins: choose Old Faithful Inn if your priority is being inside Yellowstone, watching Old Faithful eruptions on foot and staying in a landmark historic lodge with on-site full-service dining and a lodge atmosphere.
When GetAways at Timbers at Island Park wins: pick GetAways at Timbers if you need extra space, a full kitchen, an indoor pool and free self-parking and don’t mind a drive to the park entrances.
Bottom line: Old Faithful Inn is the clear choice for an in-park, historic Yellowstone experience and immediate access to geysers; GetAways at Timbers at Island Park is a practical, family-friendly off-park alternative with condo amenities and an indoor pool.
| Category | Old Faithful Inn | GetAways at Timbers at Island Park |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic, lodge-focused, intentionally 'unplugged' guest rooms and public spaces | Small resort-style condo property with practical, kitchen-equipped guestrooms |
| Location | Inside Yellowstone National Park, steps from Old Faithful and the Visitor Education Center | Island Park, Idaho — about a drive from Yellowstone park entrances; near Caribou-Targhee National Forest and Island Park Golf Course |
| Size (rooms) | About 327–329 rooms | 6 guestrooms (apartments, 2 Bedrooms) |
| Audience / age policy | All ages welcome; family-friendly | |
| Pools / water | No pool, no hot tub | Indoor pool on site (Number of indoor pools - 1) |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site outlets: Dining Room (full-service), Bear Pit Lounge, Bear Paw Deli and espresso service | Not published on-site restaurants; condo units have full kitchens |
| Spa & fitness | No spa or fitness center on site | Not published |
| Known for | Proximity to Old Faithful geyser and the Upper Geyser Basin; historic National Historic Landmark lodge | Resort-style condo lodging with kitchens, indoor pool and proximity to Island Park outdoor recreation/golf |
| Parking & front desk | Free self-parking on site; 24-hour front desk | Free self-parking on site; front desk staffed during limited hours |
| Connectivity | No in-room Wi‑Fi or internet service (intentionally unplugged); limited cell service | Complimentary WiFi available |
Old Faithful Inn sits inside Yellowstone National Park within walking distance of Old Faithful and the Upper Geyser Basin.
Choose Old Faithful Inn to be inside the park and within walking distance of the geysers.
GetAways at Timbers at Island Park is in Island Park, Idaho near forestland and an Island Park golf course, a drive from Yellowstone’s entrances.
Pick GetAways for a base in Island Park with easy driving access to park entrances and nearby outdoor recreation.
Old Faithful Inn offers a wide range of historic rooms and suites, some with shared bathrooms and most intentionally unplugged.
Old Faithful Inn is for travelers who accept historic, simplified rooms in exchange for an in-park location.
GetAways at Timbers units are condo-style guestrooms with kitchens and practical in-room amenities.
GetAways is better if you want a kitchen, more space and modern in-room conveniences.
Old Faithful Inn has several on-site dining options including a large historic Dining Room and a lounge.
Old Faithful Inn gives you full-service dining inside the park; reservations are important for dinner.
GetAways units include kitchens for cooking and the property listing does not publish on-site full-service restaurants.
GetAways suits travelers who prefer to cook or to eat off-site rather than rely on on-site full-service dining.
Old Faithful Inn does not offer a pool or hot tub; the park’s geothermal attractions are the primary draw.
If an on-site pool or spa is essential, Old Faithful Inn is not the right choice.
GetAways at Timbers at Island Park offers an indoor pool as a primary on-site recreational feature.
GetAways is a better fit for guests wanting on-site pool access and condo-style amenities.
Old Faithful Inn has limited on-site nightlife focused on the Bear Pit Lounge and evening dining; no spa or fitness facilities.
Expect quiet evenings centered on dining, the lounge and watching geysers rather than a hotel nightlife scene.
GetAways is a low-key condo property; nightlife options depend on guests leaving the property and visiting nearby Island Park venues.
Plan to drive into Island Park or surrounding towns for nightlife; the property itself is quiet after hours.

Staying steps from Old Faithful and the Upper Geyser Basin for multiple geyser viewings on foot.

Two‑bedroom apartment units with full kitchens for families or longer stays.

A National Historic Landmark lodge with a large, character-filled dining room and lodge public spaces.

On-site indoor pool for year-round swimming and family downtime.
Old Faithful Inn — it’s inside the geyser basin and within walking distance of Old Faithful; GetAways requires driving to the park.
GetAways at Timbers at Island Park — the condo units have full kitchens and more living space; Old Faithful Inn offers historic rooms without kitchens.
GetAways provides complimentary WiFi. Old Faithful Inn intentionally does not provide in-room internet or WiFi service.
GetAways — the supplier listing notes an indoor pool. Old Faithful Inn does not have a pool or spa.
Explore how Old Faithful Inn stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·