
Old Faithful Inn
Best for being inside Yellowstone and walking to Old Faithful and nearby geyser basins.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Old Faithful Inn is a landmark log lodge inside Yellowstone National Park best for travelers who want immediate access to geysers and a historic, unplugged stay. Bison at Buffalo Jump is independent West Yellowstone lodging for visitors who prefer town-based, no-frills apartments near the park’s West Entrance.
Updated · about 30 miles apart

Best for being inside Yellowstone and walking to Old Faithful and nearby geyser basins.

Best for budget-minded travelers who want an easy drive to the West Entrance and basic apartment-style lodging.
When Old Faithful Inn wins: choose Old Faithful Inn if you want to stay inside the park, be within walking distance of the Old Faithful geyser and Visitor Education Center, and experience a historic lodge with full dining and lounge options.
When Bison at Buffalo Jump wins: pick Bison at Buffalo Jump if you prefer independent, apartment-style lodging in West Yellowstone, immediate access to town services and ski trails, and free self-parking for a car-based Yellowstone visit.
Bottom line: Old Faithful Inn is the pick for the in-park, historic Yellowstone experience with on-site dining and direct geyser access; Bison at Buffalo Jump is a practical, well-rated town option for travelers basing themselves in West Yellowstone and driving into the park.
| Category | Old Faithful Inn | Bison at Buffalo Jump |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic, park-run lodge with deliberately unplugged rooms and large public spaces | Independent, practical apartment in West Yellowstone geared to outdoor activities |
| Location | Inside Yellowstone National Park next to Old Faithful and the Visitor Education Center | West Yellowstone town, within a short drive of the Park’s West Entrance |
| Size (rooms) | 327–329 rooms | Not published |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; minimum check-in age 21 (unless accompanied) | All ages welcome; check-in minimum 18 (per property listing) |
| Pools / beach | No pool, hot tub, or beach | |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site: Old Faithful Inn Dining Room, Bear Pit Lounge, Bear Paw Deli, Mezzanine espresso | Not published |
| Spa / wellness | No spa or fitness center on site | |
| Known for | Being a National Historic Landmark beside Old Faithful geyser | Proximity to Yellowstone’s West Entrance, ski trails, and town attractions |
| Parking | Free self-parking available (main lot shared with geyser area) | |
| Connectivity / rooms | Guest rooms intentionally lack TVs, radios, air conditioning, and Wi‑Fi | Apartment features include free WiFi and a flat-screen TV |
Old Faithful Inn sits inside Yellowstone next to the Old Faithful geyser and the Visitor Education Center.
Choose Old Faithful Inn for immediate access to geyser viewing and in-park convenience.
Bison at Buffalo Jump is in West Yellowstone town, a short drive from the park’s West Entrance.
Pick Bison at Buffalo Jump if you want town conveniences and easy car access to the West Entrance.
Old Faithful Inn offers a mix of named historic room types, some with private baths and some with shared bathrooms.
If a historic room and being unplugged matter, Old Faithful Inn provides the authentic in-park lodging experience.
Bison at Buffalo Jump is listed with a Basic Apartment room type and apartment conveniences.
Bison suits guests who want apartment-style basics and in-room connectivity in West Yellowstone.
Old Faithful Inn provides multiple on-site dining and bar venues with seasonal hours.
Stay at Old Faithful Inn for convenient in-house dining and the historic dining room experience.
Bison at Buffalo Jump listing does not publish an on-site restaurant or bar.
Expect to eat in town or self-cater at Bison; don’t rely on hotel dining services.
Old Faithful Inn’s main draw is location and historic public spaces rather than a pool or spa.
Old Faithful Inn’s signature amenity is direct access to geothermal features rather than recreational facilities.
Bison at Buffalo Jump focuses on proximity to outdoor activities rather than on-site water or spa facilities.
Bison is a practical base for outdoor seasons and town-based activities rather than a resort with pools or spa services.
Old Faithful Inn provides quiet public spaces and a lounge rather than a spa or nightlife district.
Old Faithful Inn is for low-key evenings in historic lounges and early starts for park exploration.
Bison at Buffalo Jump gives access to West Yellowstone’s evening options and winter-sport activities.
If you want town nightlife after a day in the park, Bison puts you within walking distance of West Yellowstone’s options.

Old Faithful Inn — walk to Old Faithful and the Upper Geyser Basin.

Old Faithful Inn — National Historic Landmark with historic dining and public spaces.

Bison at Buffalo Jump — located in West Yellowstone with easy access to shops, services, and the West Entrance.

Bison at Buffalo Jump — simple apartment with free parking and in-room WiFi for practical stays.
If being inside the park and walking to Old Faithful matters, choose Old Faithful Inn. If you prefer town services, easier parking, and a base near the West Entrance, choose Bison at Buffalo Jump.
No on-site restaurant or bar is published for Bison at Buffalo Jump; Old Faithful Inn lists several on-site dining venues.
No. Old Faithful Inn has no pool or spa; Bison at Buffalo Jump does not list a pool or spa in its supplier amenities.
Bison at Buffalo Jump lists many nearby winter activities (snowmobiling, snowboarding, sledding, snowshoeing), making it convenient for winter-sport access; Old Faithful Inn operates seasonally (typically May–mid‑October) and is closed in much of winter.
Explore how Old Faithful Inn stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·